After Pearl by Stephen G. Eoannou (Book Review #2059)

Stephen G. Eoannou’s After Pearl is a masterfully written, darkly atmospheric historical mystery that immerses readers in the morally murky world of 1940s Buffalo, just months after the attack on Pearl Harbor. At once gritty and psychologically complex, the novel introduces us to Nicholas Bishop, an alcoholic private investigator who wakes up in a hotel room with no memory of the past five days, two bullets missing from his .38 revolver, and a mounting suspicion that he may be responsible for the death of a sultry lounge singer named Pearl DuGaye.

Bishop’s hazy recollections and PTSD-fueled flashbacks to his service in World War I lend the novel a dreamlike, often nightmarish quality, as he sets off to unravel a mystery that may very well lead to his own undoing. With mobsters on his tail, cops convinced he’s guilty, and his fiercely loyal assistant Gia Alessi—who he may or may not have fired—by his side, Bishop’s descent into the dark alleys and smoky lounges of Buffalo reveals more than just a murder. Dirty politicians, crumbling socialites, a cheating husband, and even a network of American Nazis emerge from the shadows, making After Pearl a tangled web of noir brilliance.

What elevates the novel beyond a traditional gumshoe tale is the author’s deft prose and emotional nuance. Bishop is no caricature of a hard-boiled detective—he’s haunted, wounded, and desperate to find meaning in a world unraveling around him. His bond with Gia is one of the novel’s highlights: witty, electric, and tinged with unresolved tension. And his inner turmoil—balancing guilt, survival, and a search for redemption—adds a philosophical depth rare in genre fiction.

The setting of 1942 Buffalo is more than just a backdrop; it’s a living, breathing character in its own right. From snow-covered streets to whiskey-soaked piano bars, Stephen renders the post-Pearl Harbor American landscape with stunning authenticity and noir elegance. Fans of Raymond Chandler and James Ellroy will find plenty to love here, but After Pearl stands firmly on its own, unafraid to probe the emotional and political undercurrents of its era.

A Claymore Award finalist and the first in the Nicholas Bishop Mysteries, After Pearl is a compelling start to a series with immense promise. It’s a rich, moody, and compulsively readable novel that explores how trauma, loyalty, and buried secrets can shape—and shatter—a man. As much a literary journey as a suspenseful ride, this is historical noir at its best.

Written by Jeyran Main

“Want your book featured in our magazine? Feature an editorial book review in our Book Review Magazine or submit an article in our Book Article Magazine.”

“Support the writing community—purchase our magazines today!”

“Explore more reviews and find your next great read!”