A Teller of Tales by Marilyn Pemberton (Book Review #1911)

Set in Wednesbury from 1822 to 1828, “A Teller of Tales” by Marilyn Pemberton weaves a poignant and compelling narrative around Lizzie, a determined fifteen-year-old who has dedicated her life to caring for her younger brother Bobbit, who was born with significant disabilities. This historical fiction explores themes of resilience, societal constraints, and the transformative power of storytelling.

Lizzie’s world is one where girls’ aspirations are systematically crushed. Despite her extraordinary talent for crafting fairy tales about independent girls on quests, Lizzie faces a harsh reality where her dreams are dismissed. Her ambition to be a missionary is deemed unsuitable, her stories are rejected unless she changes the heroine to a hero, and she is barred from teaching, confined instead to the domestic sphere. These rejections underscore the limitations imposed on women during the 19th century.

The bond between Lizzie and Bobbit is central to the story. Lizzie is the only one who believes in Bobbit’s understanding, and she fills his world with fairy tales that empower and inspire. However, tragedy strikes when Bobbit, bullied and feeling outcast, is found dead in the canal. Lizzie fears that he took her stories too literally, ending his life in a bid for the heavenly acceptance she described.

Nathaniel, a suitor who promises Lizzie a chance to teach at a new school, proposes to her. Driven by a mixture of hope and anger—especially at John, whom she secretly loves but who seems indifferent—Lizzie accepts Nathaniel’s proposal. Yet, as John’s fate takes a dire turn with a mining accident, Lizzie’s true feelings surface. Nathaniel discovers a fairy tale Lizzie wrote that reveals her heart’s conflict, leading to their engagement’s end.

The story reaches a heartwarming resolution as John, inspired by Lizzie’s unwavering support and challenging tales, overcomes his despair. He crafts a wooden cover for Lizzie’s fairy tales with his remaining hand and eye, symbolizing his renewed purpose and love. When he presents it to Lizzie, she envisions their shared future, replying, “Our children.”

“A Teller of Tales” is not just Lizzie’s story; it’s the beginning of a legacy passed down to her granddaughter and great-granddaughter, whose lives and stories unfold in subsequent books. Pemberton masterfully blends historical context with rich character development, making Lizzie’s journey a testament to the enduring spirit of women who defy societal constraints through the power of their voice and imagination. This novel is a tribute to the resilience of the human spirit and the timeless impact of stories told from the heart.

Written by Jeyran Main

Click here to feature your book in the Review Tales Magazine.