Soft as Water by B. Robert Conklin (Book Review #1882)

B. Robert Conklin’s “Soft as Water” is a gripping psychological thriller that delves into the complexities of tragedy and redemption. Set against the backdrop of a quaint Ohio River town, the story follows Will Archer, a man haunted by his past, seeking solitude after a catastrophic accident. His plans for a reclusive life are upended by a chance meeting with Essence Warner, which spirals into a deep investigation into a cold case that is as enigmatic as it is tragic.

The plot of “Soft as Water” centers on the mysterious deaths of Essence’s parents nearly two decades ago—her socialite mother’s supposed suicide and her jazz musician father’s suspected overdose. When the musician’s mother employs Will as a curator for a museum dedicated to her son, Will finds himself unwrapping layers of small-town secrets that challenge the official narratives of the deaths. As Will and Essence grow closer, their relationship not only exposes them to danger but also to the darker corners of their own histories and motivations.

Conklin masterfully constructs a narrative that is both a romance and a thriller, weaving together personal introspection with broader societal issues. The pacing is excellent, maintaining suspense while exploring the psychological depths of the characters. Essence’s journey paralleled with Will’s, forms a poignant exploration of how the past can dictate the present if it is not confronted.

However, the novel sometimes struggles with balancing its romantic elements against the sheer weight of the darker themes it addresses. At some point, the love story between Will and Essence feels overshadowed by the intense focus on mystery, which might leave readers craving more development in their relationship.

The strengths of the book lie in its compelling mystery and the vivid setting of a small town with big secrets. Conklin’s portrayal of the Ohio River town is atmospheric, adding a rich layer of texture to the story. The resolution of the mystery is satisfying, offering a thoughtful commentary on the impact of unresolved grief and the power of truth.

“Soft as Water” is recommended for readers who appreciate thrillers that not only entertain but also offer insight into the human condition. Its blend of suspense, romance, and a dash of social commentary makes it a meaningful read that resonates well beyond its final page.

Written by Jeyran Main

Click here to feature your book in the Review Tales Magazine.